Katchatheevu Island UPSC, a small, uninhabited speck of land in the Palk Strait between India and Sri Lanka, holds an outsized significance in India-Sri Lanka relations. While seemingly insignificant on a map, the island has been a source of contention due to its historical background, strategic location, and impact on livelihoods. Understanding the historical significance of Kathactheveu Island UPSC aspirants, particularly in the context of Geography and International Relations.

Pre-Colonial Period and Conflicting Claims

The exact history of Katchatheevu remains unclear. India claims that the island belonged to the Ramnad Kingdom of Ramanathapuram, present-day Tamil Nadu. The rulers of Ramnad exercised control over the island and surrounding waters, with fishermen using it for drying nets and seeking shelter. Sri Lanka, on the other hand, bases its claim on the Portuguese occupation of the island from 1505 to 1658. However, the extent of Portuguese control and its relevance in the post-colonial era are debatable.

Colonial Era and Unresolved Delimitation

During British rule, the maritime boundary between India (then Madras Presidency) and Sri Lanka (then Ceylon) remained undefined. Though both sides used the island, no formal ownership was established. Following independence in 1947 and 1948 respectively, India and Sri Lanka inherited the maritime boundary dispute. Negotiations to delimit the maritime boundary, including Katchatheevu, took place in the 1960s but proved unsuccessful.

The 1974 Agreement and Its Aftermath

In 1974, a landmark agreement was signed between Prime Minister Indira Gandhi of India and Prime Minister Sirimavo Bandaranaike of Sri Lanka. The agreement ceded Katchatheevu to Sri Lanka. However, it allowed Indian fishermen access to a specific zone around the island for traditional fishing and permitted continued visits by Indian pilgrims to a Catholic shrine on the island.

The 1974 agreement sparked controversy in India, particularly in Tamil Nadu. Critics argued that the government had disregarded the historical claims and the island's economic importance for Indian fishermen. The agreement also coincided with growing tensions between the two countries over the Sri Lankan Civil War.

Beyond Territory: The Human Dimension

The Katchatheevu Island UPSC issue goes beyond territorial claims. It has a significant human dimension, particularly for the fishing communities in Tamil Nadu. These communities have used the island and surrounding waters for generations, and their livelihoods depend on access to these fishing grounds. The restrictions imposed by the 1976 agreement, which followed the 1974 deal and defined exclusive economic zones, have led to frequent clashes between Indian fishermen and Sri Lankan authorities.

The island also holds religious significance for both Indian and Sri Lankan Tamil communities. The presence of St. Anthony's Church attracts pilgrims from both sides, highlighting the shared cultural heritage that transcends national boundaries.

Strategic Location and Contemporary Relevance

Katchatheevu's strategic location in the Palk Strait adds another layer of complexity. The island offers a vantage point for maritime surveillance and control over crucial shipping routes. In the context of the growing influence of China in the Indian Ocean region, the island's strategic significance has gained renewed attention.

The Katchatheevu issue continues to be a sensitive topic in India-Sri Lanka relations. Finding a solution that balances Sri Lankan sovereignty with the legitimate concerns and livelihoods of Indian fishermen remains a challenge. Examining historical claims, understanding the human dimension, and acknowledging the strategic importance are all crucial for a comprehensive understanding of this complex issue.

Conclusion

The historical significance of Katchatheevu Island UPSC is not just in its contested ownership but also in its impact on livelihoods, cultural ties, and regional security. For UPSC aspirants, a nuanced understanding of this issue is essential, highlighting the interplay of historical claims, international relations, and human factors in contemporary geopolitics.

Ready to embark on your UPSC journey? Contact Tarun IAS today and take the first step towards achieving your civil service aspirations!