Budget travel has become more popular than ever, and two airlines frequently mentioned in this space are Frontier Airlines and Spirit Airlines. These ultra-low-cost carriers (ULCCs) are known for offering incredibly cheap base fares—but travelers often wonder what the real trade-offs are behind those deals. So, the big question remains: Is Frontier Airline Or Spirit Airline Better?
Let’s break this down by comparing both airlines across several key categories: pricing, baggage policies, seating and comfort, customer service, reliability, onboard experience, and overall value.
1. Pricing: Who Offers Cheaper Fares?
Both Frontier and Spirit operate on a no-frills pricing model. This means the base fare includes only your seat and a small personal item. Everything else—from carry-on luggage to seat selection—costs extra.
Spirit Airlines often edges out Frontier with slightly lower base fares, especially on short-haul routes. However, the difference can be minimal depending on the time of booking and route popularity.
Frontier Airlines, while still affordable, sometimes offers more value through bundled services like “The Perks” and “The Works.” These include checked bags, carry-on, seat selection, and early boarding for one price.
So, is Frontier Airline or Spirit Airline better for pricing? Spirit might be better for travelers looking for the absolute lowest fare, but Frontier could save you more overall if you plan to add services.
2. Baggage Policies: What’s the True Cost?
Baggage fees are one of the most complained-about aspects of both airlines. Neither includes carry-on or checked bags in their base fare. Prices vary based on when and how you pay.
Spirit’s baggage fees tend to increase the closer you get to the flight date. If you wait until you’re at the gate, you’ll pay a premium. Frontier is similar but often slightly more transparent with its bundled baggage options.
Also, Spirit has stricter size limits on personal items, while Frontier’s dimensions are a bit more forgiving. That might be the difference between a free bag or an extra charge.
In this category, is Frontier Airline or Spirit Airline better? Frontier wins for flexibility and potentially lower baggage fees, especially when bundled.
3. Seat Comfort: Which Airline Is More Comfortable?
Let’s be honest—neither airline is known for comfort. Both use high-density seating to maximize passenger numbers, which means less legroom and no seat recline (in most rows).
Spirit’s standard seats offer about 28 inches of pitch (legroom), and the seats are thinly padded. However, Spirit does offer a premium option: the Big Front Seat. This seat offers about 36 inches of pitch and a wider design, similar to domestic first class—but without the perks.
Frontier’s regular seats are comparable, with about 28-29 inches of pitch. Some aircraft offer Stretch Seats, which provide extra legroom for an additional cost, but they aren’t as wide or cushioned as Spirit’s Big Front Seat.
So, is Frontier Airline or Spirit Airline better in terms of comfort? Spirit gets the edge here, but only if you're willing to pay for the upgrade.
4. In-Flight Amenities: What Do You Get?
Neither airline provides traditional in-flight entertainment like TV screens or Wi-Fi. Don’t expect power outlets or complimentary snacks either. In fact, even water will cost you on both carriers.
Spirit sells snacks and drinks onboard, with a menu that includes light snacks and alcoholic beverages. Frontier offers similar options but often at slightly lower prices.
If you want to stay entertained or hydrated, bring your own snacks, devices, and a refillable water bottle (fill it after security).
In this regard, there’s very little to differentiate. So, is Frontier Airline or Spirit Airline better for in-flight experience? It’s a tie—both are minimalistic, so come prepared.
5. Customer Service: Who Treats You Better?
Customer service is a sore spot for both airlines. Complaints about delayed flights, long wait times, and lack of assistance are common. That said, recent efforts by both companies aim to improve customer satisfaction.
Spirit has introduced better digital tools, mobile apps, and customer service training in recent years. It also still maintains a customer support phone line.
Frontier, however, has faced criticism for eliminating its customer service phone number and pushing customers to use chatbots and online tools exclusively, which some travelers find frustrating.
So, is Frontier Airline or Spirit Airline better when it comes to customer service? Spirit has a slight edge, mainly because of its multi-channel support options.
6. Reliability and On-Time Performance
Flight delays and cancellations are part of air travel, but ULCCs like Spirit and Frontier sometimes lag behind traditional carriers in on-time performance.
However, recent data shows that Spirit has improved its reliability and on-time rates significantly. Frontier is not far behind, but it tends to be more impacted by weather and staffing issues, especially at its Denver hub.
Spirit also has a larger fleet and more daily flights, which gives it a bit more flexibility when dealing with disruptions.
So in this case, is Frontier Airline or Spirit Airline better for reliability? Spirit slightly edges out Frontier due to better on-time performance in recent quarters.
7. Route Network and Destination Flexibility
Spirit Airlines has a larger route network overall, especially in the eastern U.S. and Latin America. If you're flying to Florida, the Caribbean, or Central America, Spirit likely has more options.
Frontier focuses more on domestic routes and has strong hubs in Denver, Orlando, and Las Vegas. It's expanding into smaller regional airports as well, which can be a plus if you live outside a major city.
So, is Frontier Airline or Spirit Airline better for destinations? Spirit wins for international and East Coast travelers, while Frontier is better for those in the West or Midwest.
8. Loyalty Programs: Do They Reward Repeat Flyers?
Spirit’s Free Spirit program earns points based on dollars spent, not miles flown. The points expire after 12 months of inactivity, but the program is relatively easy to use and has clear redemption policies.
Frontier’s Miles program is based on miles flown. While the rewards can take longer to accumulate, it may benefit frequent long-haul flyers more than Spirit’s spend-based system.
Both airlines offer paid memberships—Spirit’s "$9 Fare Club" and Frontier’s "Discount Den"—that provide exclusive deals and early access to low fares.
So, is Frontier Airline or Spirit Airline better for loyalty? It depends on your travel habits. Spirit’s program benefits frequent spenders, while Frontier is more favorable to frequent flyers.
Final Verdict: Is Frontier Airline or Spirit Airline Better?
The answer depends on your travel needs, budget, and expectations. Both airlines serve a purpose: getting you from point A to point B at the lowest possible cost. But the overall experience varies depending on how much you’re willing to pay for add-ons and comfort.
Here’s a quick summary:
- Price-conscious with light baggage: Spirit might be the better option.
- Want bundled value with fewer surprises: Frontier’s packages offer more predictability.
- Care about seat comfort: Spirit’s Big Front Seat wins here.
- Prefer better customer service and reliability: Spirit slightly leads.
- Live in the West or fly domestic often: Frontier could suit you better.
- Fly internationally or to the Caribbean: Spirit has more options.
In conclusion, Is Frontier Airline Or Spirit Airline Better? It’s not a one-size-fits-all answer. If you’re an informed traveler who plans ahead, either can be a cost-effective way to travel. Just know what you’re paying for—and what you’re not.
Comments