The Pros and Cons of Invisible Fences for Dogs In Australia

There is still some debate in the community about the advantages and disadvantages of invisible dog fences. This largely comes from a lack of understanding about how an invisible dog fence works and from assumptions that they work like electric fences and cause harm to dogs.

Any dog owner who is considering using an invisible dog fence for containment or behaviour modification should first consider the pros and cons of invisible dog fences.

Pros of an Invisible Dog Fence

• Cost

Invisible fences for dogs are generally cheaper than traditional dog fences as there is very little labour cost and the amount of raw materials are minimal

• No permit required

When building a traditional dog fence it is often necessary to get a permit which can take time.

Hidden dog fences do not require a permit and can be quickly installed

• Low to no maintenance

Invisible dog fences have little to no maintenance, with the exception of an occasional battery change on the dog collar receiver or on the back up power source.

• Aesthetically pleasing

Invisible dog fences are hidden, installed either under the ground or on existing structures. This can create a more open and spacious look, showcasing gardens and your home.

• Increase roamable areas for dog

As invisible dog fences can be installed anywhere on the property, they typically increase the total “fenced area” giving your dog more space to roam.

• Scaleable with add ons

Invisible dog fences can be added to with extra dog fencing areas all controlled from the one controller, which allows your dog fenced area to grow with your dog.

• Flexible/adaptable

Hidden dog fences are very flexible and adaptable. They can be installed over all sorts of terrain, through bushes and even under water. This type of dog fencing allows you to create many different containment and exclusion zones, even allowing your creative side to shine.

• Prevent dog escaping by jumping or digging

Invisible dog fences discourage your dog from jumping over the dog fence or burrowing under it. When your dog comes too close to the invisible fence, it will hear an audible warning sound that says, “ you are getting too close!” If your dog ignores the audible cue, a stimulation signal is sent to your dog's receiver collar. This usually deters the dog from escaping, even at low settings.

• Less chance of human error

No more forgetting to shut the gate! Your invisible fence for dogs provides a permanent containment perimeter, even when you forget to shut the gate.

• Very effective with training

Invisible dog fences work very well with a comprehensive training program to positively reinforce your dog as they adapt to the invisible dog fence system.

Cons of Invisible Fences for Dogs

• Require extra behaviour training

Training requires additional time and effort on your part. You need to be prepared to put in the extra time at the outset, to ensure your pet adapts well to their new dog fencing.

• Some dogs dislike the sensation

Some dogs do not like the sensation of stimulation on the collar. This can be both a plus and a negative. It is important to introduce the invisible dog fence system to your dog at the lowest strength, combined with proper training. If this is not done it is possible your dog will develop fear or anxiety as a result of inadequate training protocols.

It is also important to understand there are safeguards built into the invisible fence system to prevent repeated stimulations being sent to your dog in the event of real distress.

• Other animals can still get in

While the invisible fence keeps your dog in, it does not prevent other animals or humans from entering. You will need to balance the threat of your dog escaping with the threat of incursions to your property.

• Power outages

Power outages have the potential to disrupt your invisible dog fence. This can be mitigated against by installing a back up, battery power supply.

The decision around using an invisible dog fence to contain your dog all comes down to what is the best choice for your dog. Clearly, there are pros and cons. It also depends on if you are prepared to put in the necessary training to provide your dog with positive reinforcement while they learn the parameters of the hidden dog fence system. It is a good idea to talk to a professional about your dog’s specific behaviour, temperament and the outcomes you are wanting to achieve.